Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., October 26, 2009 Cheshvan 8, 5770 | | Israel Time: 20:18 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
Gazans: IDF used us as 'human shields' during offensive
By Amira Hass
Tags: IDF, Hamas, Gaza, Israel News

GAZA - The question "Who is it?" was answered with: "The Israel Defense Forces." Majdi Abed Rabbo, 39, who is a Palestinian Authority (Ramallah) employee and a member of its intelligence apparatus, went down to open the door. Standing there was the son of his neighbors, Mahmoud Daher, and behind him a soldier whose rifle was jammed into Daher's back. The soldier pushed Daher aside and aimed the rifle at Abed Rabbo.

"He ordered me to pull down my pants. I pulled them down. He demanded that I raise my shirt. I raised it. That I turn around. I turned around," Abed Rabbo related. And then the room filled up with soldiers. "Twelve, or something like that."

This was in the morning of Monday, January 5, 2009, about 40 hours after the start of the Israeli ground offensive in Gaza.
Advertisement
The soldiers had already taken over Daher's house on Sunday evening, located in I'zbet Abed Rabbo, an eastern neighborhood of Jabaliya city. First they gathered the family on the ground floor. Gunfire rang out around the house. Then they moved the family up to the first floor. The family wondered why the soldiers had taken them upstairs, to the cold, uncomfortable room - parents, children, two infants and an elderly mother. But they could not refuse, and they did not yet know that the move upstairs brought them closer to the range of fire. Only later did they learn about the three fighters from Iz al-Din al-Qassam, Hamas' military wing, positioned in the empty house to the northeast of them. The regular occupants of the house, owned by their neighbor Abu Hatem, had long since gone abroad. Abed Rabbo's tall house stood next to Abu Hatem's narrow, empty one.

At about 7 A.M. on Monday, the soldiers took Shafiq Daher - a 53-year-old financial manager who gets his salary from the PA in Ramallah - as well as Mahmoud and two other sons from their home, and then separated them from each other.

The soldiers took the elder Daher to the house of his neighbor to the east, Jaber Zeydan. The door had already been broken, and the neighbors were huddled in one room. The search here, as in the four other homes Daher was forced to enter that day, was conducted in the same way: He entered first, with the soldiers behind him. One soldier placed his rifle on Daher's right shoulder, and pressed down on his left shoulder. The members of the Zeydan family were taken into the adjacent house, owned by Tawfiq Katari. The hands of all the men, including boys of 14 and 16, were tied, some behind the back, some in front.

Protecting soldiers

The soldiers also took over Katari's house on Sunday night, January 4. The Kataris, too, were rounded up and taken to the ground floor. There was shooting all around. The soldiers took up positions on one of the upper floors and turned the northeast window, close to the Abu Hatem home, into a firing position. "There was one nice soldier who told us that where we were sitting was dangerous and moved us next to an inner wall," one of the women related.

At about 9 A.M. on Monday, the soldiers took Katari's son Jamal from the house. During the next four days Jamal accompanied the soldiers and performed several tasks. He was made to enter what he estimates were 10 houses, going in first and calling on the occupants to come downstairs. He preceded the huge army bulldozer that forced its way through the neighborhood, ripping up the streets. "I am afraid the soldiers will shoot me," he told a soldier, who replied: "Don't be afraid."

In the meantime, that same Monday morning, Shafiq Daher, too, was continuing his mission of protecting Israel Defense Forces soldiers. The second house he was made to check was also empty. It belonged to the Al-Ajarmi family. Daher did not know that his two oldest sons were accompanying other groups of soldiers, and were being forced to smash holes in the walls of houses using sledgehammers. Nor did he know that at that very moment, a soldier was jamming his rifle into the back of his third son, standing at the door of Abed Rabbo's home.

Abed Rabbo himself, after being forced to smash a hole in the wall that separated his roof from his neighbors' roof and to accompany the soldiers inside, was made to enter several houses near the mosque, break into a car and then go into the Zeydan house. He was then taken to the Katari family's home, where he met Shafiq Daher and told him that his son was all right. At about 2 P.M., a soldier took him outside, pointed to the Abu Hatem house and said, according to Abed Rabbo's testimony: "There were armed people in that house. We killed them. Take off their clothes and take their weapons." At first he refused and said that was not his job. "Obey orders," he was told.

Dead or alive?

Abbed Rabbo went to the Abu Hatem house, shouting in Arabic that he was the owner. In the house, he found three very much alive members of Iz al-Din al-Qassam. They told him to leave and threatened him not to come back, "because we will shoot you." He returned to the soldiers, who made him undress and turn around, and then told them that the three were alive. The officer on hand asked to see his ID card and discovered that Abed Rabbo was a member of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas' intelligence. He was handcuffed and moved aside. He heard shooting. Then he was again sent to check the Abu Hatem house, after being told the three militants were now dead; he found one wounded and the others "all right." One of them said: "Tell the officer that if he is a man, he can come up here himself."

The soldiers didn't like what they heard. One of them cursed, said Abed Rabbo, who was handcuffed again and made to wait. It began to grow dark when he heard a helicopter approaching, followed by the sound of a missile exploding. One of the soldiers said: Now we have killed them, with a missile. Come over here. Abed Rabbo complied and saw, with horror, that the missile had struck his house.

He told the soldier that the missile had missed. "Are you majnoun [nuts]?" the soldier asked him. "No," Abed Rabbo replied. "The missile hit my house."

There was a huge mess: Water was bursting out of pipes, pieces of concrete were lying all over. And all around the shooting continued unabated, interspersed with the sounds of many explosions and helicopters flying overhead.

At about midnight, between Monday and Tuesday, Abed Rabbo was forced to go for a third time, to ascertain whether the three Hamas militants were dead. The soldiers lit the way for him. He found two of the gunmen, still alive, but buried under the rubble; the third was still holding his weapon. Abed Rabbo returned to the soldiers, stripped down again and repeated that the three were alive.

"Are you majnoun?" they demanded.

"No, I am not majnoun, I am telling you what I saw," he replied. Hungry, thirsty and with a throbbing headache, Abbed Rabbo was taken back to the Katari house.

At 6:30 A.M. he was brought out, in front of what was once his house. Soldiers brought a megaphone, he recalled later, and started to shout: "Ya, armed people, you have 15 minutes to turn yourselves in. Come down, remove your clothes, the Red Cross is here, the journalists are here, we will treat the wounded men."

The soldiers then sent a dog into the house. One of the Hamas fighters shot and killed it. The soldiers again started calling on them to come out. There was no reply. "And then a bulldozer arrived and started to demolish my house, right before my eyes." Abed Rabbo was sent into the Katari house as the bulldozer started to wreck Abu Hatem's house. He heard sporadic gunfire shots. When he emerged, two hours later, he found two of the armed men "sprawled on the demolished concrete, dead." He did not see the third man.

"What kind of army is this, which can't break into one house where there are armed men?" Abed Rabbo asked himself.

The IDF responds

Haaretz spoke with eight residents of I'zbet Abed Rabbo neighborhood, who testified that they were made to accompany IDF soldiers on missions involving breaking into and searching houses - not to mention the family members who remained in the houses the army took over, which were used as firing positions. The eight estimated that about 20 local people were made to carry out "escort and protection" missions of various kinds, as described here, between January 5 and January 12.

The IDF Spokesperson's Unit stated in response: "The IDF is a moral army and its soldiers operate according to the spirit and values of the IDF, and we suggest a thorough examination of the allegations of Palestinian elements with vested interests. The IDF troops were instructed unequivocally not to make use of the civilian population within the combat framework for any purpose whatsoever, certainly not as 'human shields.'

"Following an examination with the commanders of the forces that were in the area in question, no evidence was found of the cases mentioned. Anyone who tries to accuse the IDF of actions of this kind creates a mistaken and misleading impression of the IDF and its fighters, who operate according to moral criteria and international law."


Related articles:
  • Italian paper: Gazans say Hamas kept them in homes used by gunmen
  • Fatah loyalists: Gaza op is 'Allah's revenge' for Hamas actions
  • Security cabinet: Israel to continue Gaza offensive to pressure Egypt
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Hamas war call
    Hamas political leader: War will settle Jerusalem dispute, not talks
    J Street's challenge
    J Street convenes in Washington, but can it take on AIPAC?
      1.   amira 11:25  |  Angry Arab 20/02/09
      2.   what a shame 21:57  |  Kalle 20/02/09
      3.   IDF fighting like Hamas now 22:23  |  Mark B. 20/02/09
      4.   if true... 23:25  |  Galut 20/02/09
      5.   Sounds Like a Good Sensible Policy 23:34  |  Baruch Gold 20/02/09
      6.   It seems that the IDF gave Terrorist Every Oppurtunity To Give Up 23:41  |  Baruch Gold 20/02/09
      7.   # 3 The hate in Baruch Gold`s words 00:24  |  Boris N. 21/02/09
      8.   Just tell Hamas; War is bad... 01:00  |  GPS 21/02/09
      9.   Mark B.looking for supporters of Israel?I`m here 01:03  |  Meo 21/02/09
      10.   Human Shields 01:06  |  Sense 21/02/09
      11.   Haaretz will not post my comment 03:02  |  dudu 21/02/09
      12.   Boris hate is in your post not in Baruch`s one. 03:29  |  Meo 21/02/09
      13.   #11 Well, DUH!!!!, dudu 04:44  |  Johnboy 21/02/09
      14.   When did it happen? 05:03  |  Emily 21/02/09
      15.   Yeah yeah, just like 42 were killed in UN school 05:25  |  no credibility 21/02/09
      16.   Dudu # 11 your are 100% right 05:30  |  Pals lie 21/02/09
      17.   War is hell .... 05:35  |  Jasper 21/02/09
      18.   Amira, learn the word "allegedly", it`s useful in 05:36  |  real journalism 21/02/09
      19.   Amira 06:36  |  Gregor 21/02/09
      20.   human shields 07:53  |  rm 21/02/09
      21.   Abed Rabbo appears to be telling the truth... 10:50  |  Basil 21/02/09
      22.   IDF looking good... 14:07  |  Mark 21/02/09
      23.   Dudu- the IDF often lies also..... 14:11  |  Palestinian Brit 21/02/09
      24.   Hearsay presented as fact - typical 15:09  |  Joe Frazier 21/02/09
      25.   Emily,but Amira did proper and impartial investigation 15:20  |  Meo 21/02/09
      26.   A different way to read this tale 2nd try 15:36  |  S 21/02/09
      27.   IDF honour law, my foot! 16:58  |  No joke! 21/02/09
      28.   double standards 22:35  |  Tom 21/02/09
      29.   Human Shields 23:04  |  Michael Hugo 21/02/09
      30.   #4 Come again, Joe Frazier? 00:23  |  Johnboy 22/02/09
      31.   #26 Why stop there, S? 00:30  |  Johnboy 22/02/09
      32.   Johnboy`s fight in an empty city. 08:57  |  Well... 22/02/09
      33.   To sentimental Johnboy #31 10:23  |  S 22/02/09
      34.   #33 Not so, S 23:42  |  Johnboy 22/02/09
      35.   #32 Sigh, Well...... 23:47  |  Johnboy 22/02/09
      36.   Truth 22:46  |  Miles Stuart 27/03/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Date Local Jewish Singles
    Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    20:10 Abbas to Obama: I'll quit, there's no chance for peace with Netanyahu
    18:41 Egypt boycott of Lieberman pushes off Med Union summit
    15:59 Iran FM plays down threat of pre-emptive IDF strike
    15:01 Iran hints at acceptance of nuclear deal with West
    15:39 Peres: Unlike Hamas, Israel protects its children
    19:44 Barak: Obama envoy Mitchell due in Israel this week
    13:47 Arab MK brands Lieberman's party 'fascist' over Nakba bill
    16:57 What Netanyahu can give himself, and Israel, for his 60th birthday
    18:08 Peace Now director barred from Knesset after Borat-style video
    23:34 TV ROUND-UP: Temple Mount riots reignite; Bar Refaeli conquers Istanbul
    19:22 Israel Unposed / Peres and peers 'Facing Tomorrow'
    09:42 Soupy Sales, Rod Serling: Prophets who raised a generation
    19:40 Religious Zionist rabbis: Ascend the Temple Mount
    17:54 Fox takes down provocative Bar Refaeli billboard
    13:41 PA negotiator: Israel to blame for stalled peace talks
    11:12 Settlers: Shin Bet trying to slander us ahead of Rabin memorial
    16:40 Report: Turkey PM says Lieberman threatened to nuke Gaza
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved