Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., August 31, 2008 Av 30, 5768 | | Israel Time: 16:27 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 12:08 29/05/2008
German student to be deported for alleged 'missionary work'
By Ofri Ilani
Tags: Israel, Germany, missionary

A student from Germany is set to be deported Friday, after the Interior Ministry determined that she was doing missionary work.

Barbara Ludwig, 32, who has been living mainly in Israel for the past decade, completed her undergraduate degree in philosophy here, and is now working on her master's degree in religious studies at the Hebrew University.

"I was born in Germany, but I found my identity in Israel," Ludwig said.
Advertisement
However, at 6:30 A.M. on April 28, the Immigration Police knocked on her door and took her to Ma'asiyahu Prison in Ramle.

Despite attempts by the Hebrew University's legal department to demand her release so she could finish her studies, the Custody Tribunal at Ma'asiyahu ordered her to leave the country within 30 days.

Interior Ministry spokeswoman Sabine Haddad said Ludwig was being deported because she had not arranged her residency status. However, the head of the Population Administration's central region, Elinor Golan, sent two letters to Ludwig's lawyer stating that Ludwig's repeated requests for residency status had been denied because she was "doing missionary work."

Michael Decker, Ludwig's lawyer, said a hearing held on her case in 2004 in the Interior Ministry was a "humiliating religious interrogation," including asking whether she believed Jesus was the messiah.

Ludwig denied being a missionary, although she admits being in contact with Messianic Jews. "They may have seen me at some meeting of the Messianic Jews," she says. I go around with Jews, with Christians and with Messianics, and I read books about Christianity. So what? That's no a reason to deport me," Ludwig said.

The Interior Ministry insists that Ludwig is not being persecuted for her religious faith.

"The above has been in Israel for five years illegally, and that is the basis for the demand that she leave the country," Interior Ministry spokeswoman Haddad said. "Ms. Ludwig has been asked a number of times to leave the country and arrange her status, but she prefered to ignore the Interior Ministry's requests and continued to break the law.

"In light of the above, we see no fault with the way the issue was handled so far. On the contrary, we are surprised that the lady was a student at an official institution in the state of Israel while defined as an illegal resident," Haddad added.

Related articles:
  • Jehovah's Witnesses grow by 'devious' methods, charge anti-missionaries
  • Orthodox Jewish youths burn New Testaments in Or Yehuda
  • U.S. evangelicals raise specter of 'Islamofascism' to rouse voters
  • Loving Jesus, fearing the neighbors in Ariel
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    World War III
    A top Iranian general says an attack on Tehran would ignite a 'world war'.
    Raising the price
    Hamas says won't compromise, Israel must free 1,000 prisoners for Shalit.
      1.   messianic 12:28  |  andy 29/05/08
      2.   Lefties at HU taking law in their own hands,typical for Leftie co 12:56  |  Absolute Sweden 29/05/08
      3.   If illegal so long then the Iministry is only doing it`s job. 13:17  |  Jo 29/05/08
      4.   Persecution or not ? 13:18  |  Fussion 29/05/08
      5.   one less nutjob 13:22  |  don 29/05/08
      6.   No way was she deported for illegal status... 13:30  |  X 29/05/08
      7.   Christian minority is disadvantaged in the Middle East 13:41  |  John 29/05/08
      8.   Illegal resident bullies universitiy slots of ethiopean jews!!! 13:55  |  Alex 29/05/08
      9.   In Gaza Hamas would have shot her...Israel gave her fair trial. 14:20  |  r 29/05/08
      10.   Double standard 14:22  |  W 29/05/08
      11.   Missionaries in Israel 15:04  |  Dror 29/05/08
      12.   Sorry John #7...Europe and USA are so nice with illegals!!! 15:16  |  Alain 29/05/08
      13.   Deporting Missionaries 15:17  |  Said 29/05/08
      14.   #10 15:55  |  Jan 29/05/08
      15.   To #10, Double Standard 16:31  |  Derek 29/05/08
      16.   Dror#11 16:34  |  ron 29/05/08
      17.   I was deported too for being a missionary in Jerusalem 16:51  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/05/08
      18.   Dror, you will make a good Christian, just try to see the truth 16:55  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/05/08
      19.   very funny ron 17:05  |  Dror 29/05/08
      20.   outsider 17:08  |  Di, the doubter 29/05/08
      21.   outsider 17:09  |  Di, the doubter 29/05/08
      22.   Yaakov Sullivan 17:10  |  Dror 29/05/08
      23.   Yaakov`s deportation 17:28  |  Shirah 29/05/08
      24.   weird 18:07  |  Marsian 29/05/08
      25.   Yet Lubavitch is allowed to roam the world spreading its poison 18:22  |  Chanalau, Tova 29/05/08
      26.   Disgraceful 18:28  |  JordanisPalestine 29/05/08
      27.   MINISTRY OF INTERIOR 18:30  |  MICHAEL FURMAN 29/05/08
      28.   This is why Middle Eastern Countries, even more moderate 18:30  |  Francis 29/05/08
      29.   Tova Chanalau, 18:36  |  luther 29/05/08
      30.   #25 Chanalau, Tova 18:52  |  JordanisPalestine 29/05/08
      31.   #17 another LIE from the FAILURE 18:52  |  Ari ben Yisrael 29/05/08
      32.   Thanks for deporting 18:57  |  Advocate4Liberty 29/05/08
      33.   Let`s put it this way 19:01  |  * BEN JABO 29/05/08
      34.   #15 Derek 19:03  |  Advocate4Liberty 29/05/08
      35.   #25 Chanalu, Tovah (Rawsha) 19:04  |  * BEN JABO 29/05/08
      36.   Relax 19:06  |  Maks 29/05/08
      37.   #26 JordanisPalestine 19:11  |  * BEN JABO 29/05/08
      38.   Yakoub Suleiman anything to say Turkish Gay Association banned 19:36  |  Genuine Tosefta 29/05/08
      39.   #17 Jakoub Suleiman converting Gays is not so hard to do 19:40  |  Genuine Tosefta 29/05/08
      40.   Yakoub Suleiman #17,how many Muslims you converted in Jerusalem? 19:43  |  Genuine Tosefta 29/05/08
      41.   Comments 19:54  |  Sar Chasm 29/05/08
      42.   #15: What exactly is the status of proselytizing? 20:00  |  Jan 29/05/08
      43.   Shirah 20:12  |  Genuine Tosefta 29/05/08
      44.   Shirah 20:43  |  Shekinah 29/05/08
      45.   # 37 ben jabber 20:45  |  Axel 29/05/08
      46.   Ben Jabo 21:21  |  Shekinah 29/05/08
      47.   Messianic 22:12  |  Nelda 29/05/08
      48.   What a shame? 22:39  |  Shoshana Thomasson 29/05/08
      49.   Still waiting Yakoub Suleiman report on adopting that Arab child 23:04  |  Genuine Tosefta 29/05/08
      50.   Can you proselytize Muslims in Mecca/other Arab/Muslim country? 23:10  |  Genuine Tosefta 29/05/08
      51.   Send her to Iran or Syria 23:28  |  dm 29/05/08
      52.   I understand 23:31  |  eric 29/05/08
      53.   More Israeli inhumanity 00:09  |  Genuine Tosefta 30/05/08
      54.   Shekinah 02:49  |  Shirah 30/05/08
      55.   GT 03:52  |  Axel 30/05/08
      56.   You Know I Wouldn`t Kick Out Germans... 05:55  |  Yosemite 30/05/08
      57.   #46 Shekinah - What in the devil are you talking about? 06:40  |  * BEN JABO 30/05/08
      58.   #45 OXel - You make as much sense as usual-NONE 06:42  |  * BEN JABO 30/05/08
      59.   Baptist Village 07:56  |  Susan 30/05/08
      60.   Germans should observe carefully 09:44  |  Raymond Deane 30/05/08
      61.   Genuine Tosefta 09:46  |  Santa Claus 30/05/08
      62.   missionary work 10:11  |  ruben siedner 30/05/08
      63.   #GENUINE TOSEFTA 10:57  |  MICHAEL FURMAN 30/05/08
      64.   Shirah 12:25  |  Shekinah 30/05/08
      65.   Ben Jabo 12:50  |  Shekinah 30/05/08
      66.   "missionary work" - God`s will? Nonsense! 13:42  |  ruben siedner 30/05/08
      67.   tolerance? you should be the first 13:53  |  ruben siedner 30/05/08
      68.   #65 Shikur 18:09  |  * BEN JABO 30/05/08
      69.   Why Christian Missionaries Should be Deported 18:34  |  Reasonable Dialouge 30/05/08
      70.   #65-2 Shikur - You sound like one 19:04  |  * BEN JABO 30/05/08
      71.   Shekina - Let`s make a deal 19:46  |  * BEN JABO 30/05/08
      72.   #18 Yaacov on Dror 20:11  |  Observer 30/05/08
      73.   #18 Turncoat Sullivan 20:54  |  * BEN JABO 30/05/08
      74.   #60 Raymond Deane 21:02  |  * BEN JABO 30/05/08
      75.   #60-2 Raymond Deane 01:37  |  * BEN JABO 31/05/08
      76.   #21 Shekina - Further to my request 07:03  |  * BEN JABO 31/05/08
      77.   To Ben Jabo`s posts 08:22  |  Evangelical Woman 31/05/08
      78.   OMG! I hadn`t read your post 71 before, Mr. Jabo! 09:35  |  Evangelical Woman 31/05/08
      79.   # 52 to eric in the EU: how cute... 10:17  |  eric 31/05/08
      80.   Son of Jabo 13:42  |  Shekinah 31/05/08
      81.   Evangelical Woman 13:58  |  Shekinah 31/05/08
      82.   Ruben 14:40  |  Shekinah 31/05/08
      83.   #69 Unreasonable Dialogue 15:25  |  Shekinah 31/05/08
      84.   Ben Jabo 16:26  |  Shekinah 31/05/08
      85.   #80 Shekinah - I`m not being sarcastic, just factual 03:15  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/08
      86.   #84 Shekinah/Shikur 03:17  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/08
      87.   #78 Evangelical Woman 03:21  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/08
      88.   the crazies have come out to play 15:16  |  Dror 01/06/08
      89.   Ben Jabo 15:19  |  Ichabod 01/06/08
      90.   #89 Ichabod - Durban 15:39  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/08
      91.   # 17 en # 18.. And I`m proud to convert TO Judaism... 16:31  |  John 01/06/08
      92.   Eric Cartman and Christian rock, South Park 17:32  |  Dror 01/06/08
      93.   Dror 18:15  |  Shekinah 01/06/08
      94.   NOTICE TO ALL MISSIONAIRES 18:41  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/08
      95.   Ben Jabo 19:19  |  Shekinah 01/06/08
      96.   Shekaka 19:27  |  Dror 01/06/08
      97.   Hashem is the farthest thing from you Shakookoo 19:40  |  Dror 01/06/08
      98.   Dror 19:50  |  Shekinah 01/06/08
      99.   Dror 19:57  |  Shekinah 01/06/08
      100.   If you are genuinely interested 20:16  |  Dror 01/06/08
      101.   Getting into religious debates with shishi 20:27  |  Dror 01/06/08
      102.   Dror - About being Jewish 21:50  |  Shekinah 01/06/08
      103.   #73 As Brother Nathanael said once, they never learn... 22:59  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/06/08
      104.   #23 Shira. I would LOOVE for somebody to convert Hassan, I can`t 23:11  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/06/08
      105.   Deadline has passed 02:50  |  * BEN JABO 02/06/08
      106.   Just think - Those pretending to represent G-d 02:52  |  * BEN JABO 02/06/08
      107.   # 87 He`ll NOT be contacting you, Ben Jabo 06:46  |  Evangelical Woman 02/06/08
      108.   #78, Evangelical woman 07:41  |  Advocate4Liberty 02/06/08
      109.   Advocate for what? 10:23  |  Ichabod 02/06/08
      110.   it`s don`t come clean 11:19  |  Manolo 02/06/08
      111.   Jesus can forgot and forgive -but I don`t 11:33  |  Manolo 02/06/08
      112.   Lord penalty can will be WORST 11:48  |  Manolo 02/06/08
      113.   A truly democracy never do that 12:12  |  Manolo 02/06/08
      114.   Shekinah you sound like a Karaite 13:37  |  Dror 02/06/08
      115.   #108 That I shall dear Advocate4Liberty 13:45  |  Evangelical Woman 02/06/08
      116.   Christianity threw a wrench into the gears 13:46  |  Dror 02/06/08
      117.   Dror, read Paul` letters by your own 15:06  |  Manolo 02/06/08
      118.   to manolo #111 (PART I) 15:12  |  ruben siedner 02/06/08
      119.   to Manolo #111 (PART II) 15:15  |  ruben siedner 02/06/08
      120.   Dror 15:33  |  Shekinah 02/06/08
      121.   Ruben 15:48  |  Shekinah 02/06/08
      122.   Manolo, Haaretz refuses to post my responses to you 15:57  |  Dror 02/06/08
      123.   Shekinah 16:23  |  Dror 02/06/08
      124.   To add to my previous comments 16:30  |  Dror 02/06/08
      125.   Praise Jesus 16:41  |  Dror 02/06/08
      126.   Manolo 17:28  |  Cla 02/06/08
      127.   When all is said and done. 17:42  |  The LORD, YHWH. 02/06/08
      128.   Arguing prejudices 18:45  |  Manolo 02/06/08
      129.   When the jews will apologize? 18:47  |  Manolo 02/06/08
      130.   Mmmmmmhhh... 18:50  |  Manolo 02/06/08
      131.   truly jew heritage 19:05  |  Manolo 02/06/08
      132.   Dror - Tell the truth 19:09  |  Shekinah 02/06/08
      133.   Manolo NO NO 19:35  |  Ichabod 02/06/08
      134.   German student to be deported 20:02  |  sarah 02/06/08
      135.   PLAYTIME IS OVERE 20:13  |  * BEN JABO 02/06/08
      136.   # 135 what a pleasant surprise, ben jabo! 23:18  |  eric 02/06/08
      137.   Outdated immigration policy 02:19  |  TOBIAS RÜGER 03/06/08
      138.   #129 Manolo AS A JEW I APOLOGIZE FOR KILLING THIS GUY JESUS 08:42  |  JEW 03/06/08
      139.   from Ruben to Manolo 08:59  |  ruben siedner 03/06/08
      140.   Yes, I`m comprendo 10:21  |  Manolo 03/06/08
      141.   Yeas, I can forgive and forgot -can you? 10:49  |  Manolo 03/06/08
      142.   If you claim for free, you must offer free 10:55  |  Manolo 03/06/08
      143.   Partisans are not `civilians` 11:04  |  Manolo 03/06/08
      144.   Quit this story already 16:43  |  Dror 03/06/08
      145.   #142 Manol - Tell me, what part of 17:51  |  * BEN JABO 03/06/08
      146.   No no Manolo 18:55  |  Shekinah 03/06/08
      147.   Dror 19:01  |  Shekinah 03/06/08
      148.   #138 JEW - I DON`T THINK SO 22:56  |  * BEN JABO 03/06/08
      149.   MISSIONARY WORK GERMAN STUDENT 22:58  |  DAVID HARRIS 03/06/08
      150.   #111 To Manolo 23:51  |  eric 03/06/08
      151.   Comment to David 07:41  |  Shekinah 04/06/08
      152.   Read ALL the passages -not ones fair to you 12:10  |  Manolo 04/06/08
      153.   #152 To Manolo 13:47  |  eric 04/06/08
      154.   To Jews for Jesus living in Israel and abroad 15:07  |  Dror 04/06/08
      155.   Manolo 15:11  |  Shekinah 04/06/08
      156.   Jew not for Jesus - Dror 17:44  |  Jew for Jesus 04/06/08
      157.   Jew Foe Jesus 18:17  |  Dror 04/06/08
      158.   It is in the prophets Jew for Jesus, it is all there 18:29  |  Dror 04/06/08
      159.   to 137 18:31  |  Harry 04/06/08
      160.   Jew for JC 18:45  |  Dror 04/06/08
      161.   Dror 19:36  |  Jew for Jesus 04/06/08
      162.   Dror 19:45  |  Jew For Jesus 04/06/08
      163.   Jew for Jesus 20:58  |  Dror 04/06/08
      164.   Jew for JC 21:04  |  Dror 04/06/08
      165.   missionary 12:59  |  Naim S. Mahlab 05/06/08
      166.   Deporting student 15:36  |  Brod 05/06/08
      167.   #166 BROD - Start reading 17:20  |  * BEN JABO 05/06/08
      168.   #166 2ND TRY BROD 05:52  |  * BEN JABO 06/06/08
      169.   Ben Jabo #168 05:04  |  Brod 07/06/08
      170.   Shekinah, my wicked heart compels me to tell you 09:21  |  Dror 07/06/08
      171.   2ND TRY #169 Brod - Heading are intended to grab attention 17:17  |  * BEN JABO 07/06/08
      172.   arrest of missionary 13:34  |  vicki 08/06/08
      173.   #172 vicki - Try actually reading the article 16:42  |  * BEN JABO 08/06/08
      174.   i was wrong 12:36  |  vicki 09/06/08
      175.   #174 Vicki - I`ll claify it for you, best I can 20:06  |  * BEN JABO 10/06/08
      176.   to ben jabo 10:08  |  vicki 11/06/08
     Read & React
    Top Iran general: Attack on Tehran will ignite 'world war'
    Responses: 119
    Shas chief: Olmert has no authority to decide Jerusalem's fate
    Responses: 85
    Zvi Bar'el: If Russia becomes involved in Mideast conflict it may be cause for panic
    Responses: 11
    Editorial: Are we ready to accept Shalit's murder, knowing he could've been freed?
    Responses: 32


    More Headlines
    15:06 Olmert meets with Abbas, draws fire for Jerusalem proposal
    13:43 Shalit family: No more prisoner releases without Gilad
    10:35 Hamas making $20 million a month from Gaza smuggling tunnels
    11:22 Democratic Rep.: Palin pick is 'direct affront to all Jewish Americans'
    02:21 ANALYSIS / A giant failure called Afghanistan
    08:04 Nazi collaborator fled arrest, living peacefully in Germany
    16:10 Woman who allegedly drowned son banned from funeral for fear father's family might harm her
    03:49 This Hyphenated Life post four / The capital of the Jewish World
    14:13 New Orleans residents ordered to evacuate as Hurricane Gustav nears
    11:27 Where are Israel's 3,500 elementary school drop-outs?
    08:03 Openly bisexual Jewish-American basketball player tries out for Maccabi Haifa
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    MBA in Israel in English
    APPLY NOW! Limited spaces available
    Israel's Premier Real Estate Website
    www. israel-property.com
    Hebrew Summer courses
    From $39.95
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved